SafeSoy
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this site at no extra cost to you.Editorial Policy

Head to Head

American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making vs Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver

Deciding between the American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making and the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver? We break down every spec, feature, and trade-off so you can pick the right fragrance product for your space.

Our Pick

American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making

American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making edges out the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver thanks to its higher rating (4.7 vs 4.5). That said, the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver is still a strong choice if its specific strengths align better with your needs.

01 / Specs

Specs comparison

SpecAmerican Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle MakingDr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver
PriceCheck PriceCheck Price
Rating4.7/5Winner4.5/5
CategoryCandles FragranceCandles Fragrance

02 / Pros & Cons

What we like, what to know

American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making

What we like

    Worth knowing

    • −Availability and price change often — confirm on Amazon before buying.

    Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver

    What we like

      Worth knowing

      • −Availability and price change often — confirm on Amazon before buying.

      03 / Who It's For

      Who should buy which?

      Choose A

      The American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making

      You are soy candles & fragrance.

      Choose B

      The Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver

      You are soy candles & fragrance.

      04 / The Verdict

      The verdict

      Both the American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making and the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver are quality home fragrance products, but they serve different needs. The American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making is a candles fragrance with a 4.7-star rating, while the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver falls in the candles fragrance category with a 4.5-star rating.

      Our recommendation: Go with the American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making for its higher rating (4.7 vs 4.5). However, the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver remains a compelling option if its specific strengths align better with how you plan to use it.

      American Soy Organics Millennium Wax - Bag of Natural Soy Wax for Candle Making

      4.7/5 stars

      Read full review →

      Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver

      4.5/5 stars

      Read full review →