Head to Head
BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) vs Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver
Deciding between the BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) and the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver? We break down every spec, feature, and trade-off so you can pick the right fragrance product for your space.
Our Pick
Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver
Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver edges out the BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) thanks to its higher rating (4.5 vs 4.4). That said, the BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) is still a strong choice if its specific strengths align better with your needs.
01 / Specs
Specs comparison
| Spec | BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) | Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Check Price | Check Price |
| Rating | 4.4/5 | 4.5/5Winner |
| Category | Candles Fragrance | Candles Fragrance |
02 / Pros & Cons
What we like, what to know
BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1)
What we like
- +STRONG HOLD WITH MATTE FINISH - This premium hair clay for men by BASED gives you a matte finish with strong hold that lasts all day, but is also reworkable for a much more natural look than other products.
- +EASILY ADD VOLUME AND TEXTURE - Similar to our signature texture powder, our hair clay will instantly add volume & texture to your hair. It’s best used on normal to thick straight, or wavy hair. We recommend using Clay if your hair is shorter to medium in length. Pair with our Sea Salt Spray to lock in your beachy waves all day.
- +EASY TO USE - We designed our premium hair clay with ease of use in mind, so you can spend less time on your hair and more time being you. Simply coat the tip of your index finger in clay and warm in your hands until it's evenly broken down. Then all that’s left is to style the way you like. After your day is done it washes out in the shower and you’re ready to style again the next day.
Worth knowing
- −Details reflect the manufacturer's listing, not independent testing.
- −Availability and price change often — confirm on Amazon before buying.
Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver
What we like
Worth knowing
- −Availability and price change often — confirm on Amazon before buying.
03 / Who It's For
Who should buy which?
Choose A
The BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1)
You are soy candles & fragrance.
Choose B
The Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver
You are soy candles & fragrance.
04 / The Verdict
The verdict
Both the BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) and the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver are quality home fragrance products, but they serve different needs. The BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) is a candles fragrance with a 4.4-star rating, while the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver falls in the candles fragrance category with a 4.5-star rating.
Our recommendation: Go with the Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver for its higher rating (4.5 vs 4.4). However, the BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1) remains a compelling option if its specific strengths align better with how you plan to use it.
BASED Hair Clay for Men, Premium Hair Clay with Strong Hold, Texturizing Finish, & Low Shine, Hair Styling for Medium, Thick, Straight, or Wavy Hair, Santal Sandalwood Fragrance (3oz Pack of 1)
4.4/5 stars
Read full review →Dr. Squatch Men's Cologne - Natural Cologne made with sustainably-sourced ingredients - Manly fragrance of pine, cypress, and vetiver
4.5/5 stars
Read full review →